Classic Banoffee Pie

There are about a million banoffee pie recipes out there. Most of them are the same, and to be honest; I doubt mine is any different. But, I wanted to share it because it’s one of our favourites. It was one of the first things I ever made for Husband when we moved in together, and it’s what he asks for if ever I offer to make something.

slice of banoffee pie

I love the textures of banoffee pie. It’s not a pie at all, really is it? The base is cheesecake like, but then cheesecake isn’t a cake. Anyway… I love the textures of most things fruity. Like my apple and cinnamon cake, I love when you get a mouthful of refreshing fruit around all the other bits. Biscuit, caramel, bananas, and cream, really what could be better? Also, banoffee pie has banana’s in it. So, it’s healthy and totally fine to eat for breakfast. If you have a big enough slice, it could even be one of your five a day! Does that count? Is that how it works?


For the Base

  • 200g Digestive biscuits
  • 75g Butter

For the Filling

  • 75g Butter
  • 100g Brown Sugar
  • 400g Evaporated Milk
  • 3 Large Bananas
  • 300ml Double cream
  • 1 Square Chocolate

banoffee pie ingredients


Now, some recipes tell you to put the tin of evaporated milk in boiling water, and it turns into caramel in the can. I’m sure this probably does work, but scared me a bit, so that’s not what I did! I also didn’t use brown sugar, we ran out, so it was a bit of brown sugar but mainly caster, which worked fine, so use whatever you’ve got!

Another change I sometimes make is the base. I have done it with chocolate chip cookies and hobnobs which give it a different flavour and texture. They all work really well.

First, you want to lightly grease a tin. I use a loose bottomed pie tin, you could use a cake tin, but with sticky things like this, loose bottom makes it much easier and I highly recommend.

Crush the biscuits into crumbs. You could do this in a food processor, but I tip them into a mixing bowl and bash them with a heavy rolling pin. I enjoy this immeasurably and like to think that I’m getting a work out! They don’t need to be perfect, and a few lumps are okay, it’s all got to come together for the base anyway. Melt the butter and stir into the biscuit, so the mixture is even.

crumbed biscuits

Tip out into the pie tin and use a spoon or your fingers to press out into the sides and compress it, so it’s tight, like a cheesecake base.

biscuit base, in tin

Put this is the fridge for at least an hour, the longer, the better though really, you could even do it the night before.

While you are waiting for your base to harden, make the caramel.

To do this, add the sugar and butter to a saucepan and gently heat, stirring constantly.

When it’s all melted together, add the evaporated milk. I totally did this wrong and added them all together, it still works, but took a lot longer to thicken.

Bring the mixture to a simmer, stirring constantly. Keep simmering and stirring until the mixture thickens and darkens in colour. This should take around 20 minutes. Do not stop stirring or it will burn, or even boil over. If it is boiling up, remove from the heat for a few seconds and stir well. Whatever you do, don’t touch it, it’s incredibly hot.

caramel in pan

Once it’s thickened, turn off the heat and leave the caramel in the pan to cool gradually. It will thicken further while cooling.

Remove the base from the fridge and spoon on the caramel, spreading evenly.

caramel layer

Slice the bananas and lay them on top.

banana layer

Whisk your double cream until it’s thick. Don’t be tempted to over whisk or it will go weird!

Spoon the cream on top and spread to the edges.

cream layer on banoffee pie

Grate over a square of chocolate. Most recipes will call for dark, but I prefer milk, use whatever you like!

grated chocolate top

You can serve this straight away, but I’d advise leaving it to sit in the fridge for an hour to set.

Banoffee pie is super easy to make, the perfect quick dessert!

banoffee pie, slice and banana layer

Classic Banoffee Pie

Super simple, but perhaps the best dessert ever!
Prep Time1 hr 45 mins
Total Time1 hr 45 mins
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: British
Keyword: banana
Servings: 12 Slices
Calories: 400kcal
Author: Donna


For the Base

  • • 200g Digestive biscuits
  • • 75g Butter

For the Filling

  • • 75g Butter
  • • 100g Brown Sugar
  • • 400g Evaporated Milk
  • • 3 Large Bananas
  • • 300ml Double cream
  • 1 Square Chocolate


  • Grease a cake tin
  • Bash the biscuits into crumbs
  • Melt the butter and add to the mixture
  • Stir until even
  • Tip into the tin and spread to the edges
  • Compress using the back of a spoon
  • Place in the fridge for at least an hour
  • For the caramel, add the butter and sugar to a saucepan and gently heat
  • When melted together, add the evaporated milk
  • Mix together and Bring to a simmer, stirring constantly
  • Continue to stir for around 20 minutes until thickened
  • Turn off the heat and leave to cool
  • Once cool, spoon over the biscuit base
  • Add a layer of sliced bananas
  • Whisk the cream until it forms peaks
  • Spoon over the bananas and spread evenly
  • Grate over some chocolate
  • Either serve immediately or leave in the fridge until required.


Time include cooling times.
I use a loose bottomed 10" flan tin. 




Sharing is caring!

Related Posts

Haggis Cottage Pie with Swede and Potato Mash

Haggis Cottage Pie with Swede and Potato Mash

I’ve never had haggis before. I don’t think. Certainly not that I remember. This week was my first go at experimenting with what I could do with it. I was surprised to find it tastes like faggots. Husband doesn’t know what faggots are (and Grammarly […]

Homemade Chocolate Hobnobs

Homemade Chocolate Hobnobs

As far as I’m concerned, biscuits, especially hobnobs are the best thing ever. A biscuit (pack of) and a cup of tea are my ultimate weakness. I eat about 7, then decide I must finish the packet and the hide the evidence. At one point, […]

Leave a Reply

Your e-mail address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.